Book Club,  Book Review,  Gothic,  Mystery,  Suspense

Book Review: The Broken Girls | Simone St. James

December 27, 2018 /

Haunting, captivating, chilling, and brilliant—in a story about a place where society sent the misfits, the unwanted, the forgotten, and the ghosts, I discovered a story about how these forgotten women discovered their voices. To me, the voices of the girls in this novel were like a symphony—they were the voices of girls who were mistreated but powerful when they found one another, and they’ll stay with me long after reading it.

About the Book

Vermont, 1950. There’s a place for the girls whom no one wants–the troublemakers, the illegitimate, the too smart for their own good. It’s called Idlewild Hall. And in the small town where it’s located, there are rumors that the boarding school is haunted. Four roommates bond over their whispered fears, their budding friendship blossoming–until one of them mysteriously disappears. . . . 

Vermont, 2014. As much as she’s tried, journalist Fiona Sheridan cannot stop revisiting the events surrounding her older sister’s death. Twenty years ago, her body was found lying in the overgrown fields near the ruins of Idlewild Hall. And though her sister’s boyfriend was tried and convicted of murder, Fiona can’t shake the suspicion that something was never right about the case.

When Fiona discovers that Idlewild Hall is being restored by an anonymous benefactor, she decides to write a story about it. But a shocking discovery during the renovations will link the loss of her sister to secrets that were meant to stay hidden in the past–and a voice that won’t be silenced. . . .

Reflection

Sometimes I read a book and I struggle to do it justice in my review. This is one of those books for me, because I don’t know how to highlight all of the wonderful aspects of the story in a single review. The intricate weaving of Fiona’s investigation in 2014, her sister Deb’s murder in 1994, and the girls of Idlewild Hall in 1950 is masterful. Each story is so compelling, that I looked forward to reading more.

As the story progresses, I felt pulled towards the story in 1950, which became my obsession along with Fiona’s. And when the pieces of the three stories come together in the end, it was so perfect that I couldn’t believe I hadn’t understood that this was how it would all end. Of course this is how the story will end! It was perfect—I felt pensive and elated, energized and peaceful.

Fiona can’t let her sister’s murder twenty years earlier go. She’s completely haunted, and in a way Fiona has never truly lived her life. Remaining in her small town, she still wants to understand why Deb was left for dead in that yard for the abandoned boarding school for girls. I loved Fiona, and in her own way she is one of the broken girls from the title, though she lived. Fiona is passionate but fragile—I loved the way her mind followed the story and put the pieces together.

The Idlewild girls from the 1950s will totally steal your heart! Katie is beautiful and tough, but maybe not as strong as she seems. Cece is loyal and caring, and consistently underestimated. Roberta is strong and loving, hiding demons that haunt her. And Sonia is small and quiet, but she has a strength that others don’t realize. Their friendship and stories are mesmerizing and dark.

These are girls who society decided are problems. They are written off as troubled, but as you learn more about them, they haven’t done anything to be considered that way. Their crime is being born in a time when society didn’t accept them and support them. Sent to Idlewild where they can quickly be forgotten by their families, these girls are not ones to brushed aside. A group of lost, broken girls find strength through their pure friendship, love, and support. I will think about these four girls for years to come. They were the best part of the book for me—their stories and the melding of their voices are so beautiful.

I loved the spooky, ghost story element to this novel. It was truly a chilling aspect to the novel that was handled so well. I wondered if Mary Hand was real or a legend? As more stories circulated, her figure became such a big part of the novel that really was a delight!

I won’t say much more so that readers can form their own opinions as they read this, but I do want to say again how happy the ending made me. It was completely perfect. I loved what was tied up, and what was left to imagine what is still to come. I love that we got answers, but there are some things that really can’t be answered in words. I loved the way all of the stories got a conclusion. Just wonderful!

I missed The Broken Girls the first time around, but I was fortunate to get a chance to read it this time for the paperback release! If you didn’t order this book yet, now is the perfect time. I absolutely LOVED this book!

You May Also Like

BOOK REVIEW: The Mother-In-Law by Sally Hepworth @sallyhepworth @stmartinspress #bookreview #themotherinlaw

April 24, 2019

Book Review: The Ex-Wife | Jess Ryder

June 3, 2018

Book Review: Sister of Mine | Laurie Petrou

August 12, 2018

24 Comments

  • carhicks

    December 29, 2018 at 4:28 pm Reply

    You hit the nail on the head with this review Mackenzie. I really enjoyed this story when I read it. I was a bit concerned about the ghost story part, but I shouldn’t have worried, it was well done throughout.

  • Anonymous

    May 6, 2025 at 3:51 pm Reply

    Zenith HACKERS Intelligent offers specialized services for recovering lost cryptocurrency.

    Hello everyone, I wanted to share my recent experience with Zenith Hackers Intelligent, who successfully assisted me in recovering my lost cryptocurrency after encountering a fraudulent broker. Their expertise was invaluable, and I highly recommend their services. For more information, please visit their website at https://zenithhackers.com/ or contact them directly at zenithintel@consultant.com.

  • legendaryalways83b83012ac

    May 8, 2025 at 4:20 pm Reply

    Cryptocurrency Romance Scam Recovery Expert – Fast Swift Cyber Services Today

    Fast Swift Cyber Services specializes in helping individuals recover funds lost to cryptocurrency romance scams or investment scams. Their solid reputation in the field is built on dedication and integrity. They provide regular updates, guidance, and work relentlessly on each case. While they don’t promise quick fixes, they show significant progress over time. If you’ve been a victim of such scams, consider reaching out to them for support.

    FAST SWIFT CYBER SERVICES contact details:
    WhatsApp: +1 812.3800,994
    Email: fastswift @ cyberservices . com
    Website: https://fastswiftcyberservices.com

  • rollinsfried

    October 27, 2025 at 2:00 am Reply

    HOW I GOT MY BITCOIN BACK // WITH THE HELP OF GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER

    I was recently scammed out of $468,000 by a fraudulent Bitcoin investment. This special group of professional GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER was able to recover my money within 12hours. I’m really glad such a group exists and I’m happily sharing this out there with anyone who needs their service to recover their money. You can contact them at

    Email: geovcoordinateshacker@gmail.com
    Website; https://geovcoordinateshac.wixsite.com/geo-coordinates-hack .
    It was such a huge relief for me and I’m so grateful

  • wefredzero

    November 12, 2025 at 5:05 am Reply

    WHAT CAN I DO TO RECOVER MY STOLEN BITCOIN? CONSULT // GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER
    
    I have read a lot of stories about people losing money to investment scams. I too have been a victim of this scams. I lost about $700 in Bitcoin some months ago, I searched around and tried to work with people ,unfortunately I was scammed as well. This happened for months until I came across GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER. I would first want to thank GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER for their professional support and unshakable devotion, which resulted in the successful recovery of my money. I would highly recommend them to anyone in need of such services. Details for getting in touch: Email:
    
    Email: geovcoordinateshacker@gmail.com
    
    Website; https://geovcoordinateshac.wixsite.com/geo-coordinates-hack
    
    Telegram: @Geocoordinateshacker
    

  • THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT

    January 14, 2026 at 11:56 pm Reply

    THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT // THE BEST RECOVERY EXPERTS

    I cannot express enough gratitude for THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT. They are truly the leading experts in the field and deserve every bit of praise for recovering cryptocurrency wallets when all hope seems lost. Thanks to their intervention, I can finally reclaim peace of mind and focus on rebuilding my financial future with renewed confidence. I highly recommend anyone in a similar situation, details below to get in touch with them right now.

    web: https://thehackangels.com

    Mail Box; support@thehackangels.com

    Whatsapp; +1(520)-200,2320

  • GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER

    February 24, 2026 at 7:17 pm Reply

    BITCOIN RECOVERY IS VERY MUCH REAL // HOW I RECOVER MY LOST BITCOIN FROM FAKE BROKER ONLINE

    There are a lot of cases of Cryptocurrency theft that are becoming rampant and frustrating. A lot of people out there have already turned it to a means of depriving innocent people of their hard earned funds. I lost all my money to a fake cryptocurrency investment platform. I didn’t do enough research and I was scammed of my hard-earned money after falling victim to a cryptocurrency investment scam. I made all efforts to get back my money but to no success, I contacted the authorities as well but they couldn’t do anything to recover my funds until I was told about GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER, a cryptocurrency recovery company that has helped other scam victims recover their funds. I contacted them immediately and provided all the necessary information needed to help them with their investigation. It’s through GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER. I came to know, Bitcoin recovery is very possible as long as you are in the hands of a very good professional and trustworthy hacker. I will always be grateful for the job well done. So, catch them up for your lost funds through their email

    Email: geovcoordinateshacker@gmail.com

    Website; https://geovcoordinateshac.wixsite.com/geo-coordinates-hack

    ​
    Telegram @Geocoordinateshacker

Let me know your thoughts!!

Verified by MonsterInsights