Book Review,  Psychological,  Psychological Thriller,  Thriller

Book Review: Love Letters to a Serial Killer | Tasha Coryell

An unhinged, self-absorbed narrator begins writing to an accused serial killer in Love Letters to a Serial Killer. I found this book so fun—if you enjoy unlikable narrators, this is a great read!

What is Love Letters to a Serial Killer about?

Thirty-something Hannah works a low-paying communications job at a nonprofit that she is quietly miserable in. Not miserable enough to find a different job, but miserable enough to long for something else. After a guy she was hooking up with ghosts her for another woman and her friend Meghan gets into a serious relationship, Hannah is even more unhappy.

She finds some level of engagement in a true crime forum online, where a community is on a mission to solve the murder of a beautiful woman named Anna Leigh. A forum member is searching the ravine where Anna Leigh was found and discovers another body. When a third and fourth are found, it becomes clear that a serial killer is at work. Not long after, a handsome and wealthy lawyer named William is arrested for the murders and awaits trials.

Hannah feels angry and bored after William’s arrest, and so she begins to write letters to him. When William responds, Hannah is intrigued. Her interest transforms from curiosity to obsession, and she torpedoes her life without any regard to the fallout. After losing her job, Hannah drives to Georgia to attend William’s trial where she meets a few other women who have as unhealthy of a fixation as she does. And when William is found not guilty, things finally seem to be looking up for Hannah. Unless William really is a serial killer… Hannah knows she needs to find out the truth or die trying.

What did I think?

I suspect this book won’t be for everyone (but aren’t those sometimes the best books?). Hannah is self-absorbed and illogical to a maximum extent, and those who need to understand why someone makes the decisions they do (and agree with them) probably won’t find Hannah to be the most relatable. At the same time, she is the sort of unhinged narrator that positively tickles me. She has terrible takes on everything, justifies her own laziness and self-centered nature by making herself a victim, and judges everyone around her for trying to engage with her as a friend. On her friend Meghan getting a boyfriend, Hannah muses:

“For so long, the two of us had pined over men together and she had gone and gotten herself a man without me. Sometimes the deepest betrayals were things that women did to one another.”

Hannah often made me laugh with her bizarre and unexpected takes on life. I thought she was a lot of fun, and the audiobook narration by Andi Arndt is perfection. Arndt expertly captures Hannah’s absurd and self-indulgent voice, bringing to life this story of a woman who spent her life doing the should, only to find herself miserable and unsure how to voice it. Despite her unlikability, Hannah had these moments of vulnerability and raw insight that made her at times verging on relatable.

“It was hard, even for those of us who hadn’t been accused of killing anyone, to love ourselves. Oftentimes I found it easier to accept the bad things that happened to me than the good. If only because I struggled to find myself worthy of anything rewarding.”

Hannah’s spiral that led her to write letters to an accused serial killer isn’t what I expected. She had been seeing a guy named Max (primarily they were just hooking up, but she hoped it would eventually turn to more) when he ghosts her, moves on to another girl, and blocks her on social media. This all coincides with the first murder, and Hannah gets involved with an online true crime forum where she gets overly invested in the case. As more bodies are discovered, Hannah becomes obsessed. Absurdly, she seems to find a connection between what she went through with Max and what the women are going through. This is what prompts her to write to William, telling him off as though he were the one who ghosted her.

“This was not to suggest that being murdered and being shunned by a boy that I wasn’t even in a real relationship with were equivalent, but to say that it was a bad time for a lot of us.”

Eventually, Hannah’s obsession with the case leads her to lose her job. But not only did Hannah not enjoy her job, by this point she is all consumed by William. Hannah attends the trial, and she meets a few other true crime junkies obsessed with the case. They are an odd trio and I found it amusing how they simultaneously are one another’s only support who truly gets it, but also how they are sort of in competition with one another. When William is released from prison, Hannah and him settle down and that is when the fun begins. Hannah is constantly collecting tidbits that are either in support of or against William being a serial killer. For his part, William doesn’t confess nor deny the crimes. Is he truly a serial killer? And if so, who is his accomplice for the fifth murder that happened while he was in prison?

“I was always doing that, denying myself immediate pleasure for the sake of setting a scene.”

This is a wild story and the ending is somehow even more wild than I even expected! Enjoy the ride here—this book has a lot to unpack when you get to the end and trust me, you won’t see it coming!

Thank you to Berkley Publishing for my copy. Opinions are my own.

11 Comments

  • Hybrid Chicago

    U svojoj ulozi radim s odjelima za osiguranje, obradu, financiranje i drugim odjelima. Svaki od ovih timova dolazi s ogromnim bogatstvom znanja. To mi omogućuje da steknem više znanja o svojoj ulozi i pružim članovima bolje iskustvo. Dobijte svoju financijsku slobodu od nas danas. Dugujete li, trebate zajam, brz i pouzdan, ovo je mjesto za dobivanje vjerodostojnih zajmova. Nudimo poslovne zajmove, studentske zajmove, stambene zajmove, osobne zajmove itd. Kamatna stopa zajma od 3%. Kontaktirajte nas danas. Imate priliku dobiti novčani zajam u iznosu od 2000 (€$£) – 5.000.000 – 100.000.000 (€$£) s mogućnošću otplate od 1 godine do 45 godina bez jamstva nekretnine.
    Viber: +385915608706
    WhatsApp: +385915608706
    E-pošta: hybridalliantcreditunion@gmail.com
    © 2025 Alliant Credit Union
    11545 W. Touhy Ave., Chicago, IL 60666
    Usmjeravanje #271081528

  • Anonymous

    A friend and also a colleague from work told me he saw some testimonies of a spiritualist called Doctor Muna, he can bring back lover within some few days, Ridiculously, I laughed it out and said I am not interested but for the sake of friendship, she consulted this God sent man on my behalf and to my greatest surprise after 12 hours my husband called me for the very first time for over 7 months saying “I miss you babe and I’m so sorry for everything I made you went through” I couldn’t say a word but cried over the phone and hanged up. We are back together and living Happily together again. To be honest, I still can’t believe it, because it’s highly unbelievable. Thank you DOCTOR MUNA for bringing back my love and also to my SELFLESS FRIEND. Laura, who interceded on my behalf. For anyone who might need help of this wonderful spiritualist here is the email address: marvelspelltemple@gmail.com, Also text him on WhatsApp: +2347035449257

  • Ross Colby

    I’d like to recommend the Morphohack Cyber Security team if you ever intend to recover your Bitcoin, USDT, or other crypto assets.
    I happen to be one of many people who lost their crypto assets after a distasteful experience with a fake crypto investment scam. They kept requesting more deposits in order to “grant” me access to my wallet. If not for the intervention of the Morphohack Cyber Security team, I would have lost everything completely.
    Morphohack intervened on my behalf and began what seemed to be a full recovery process and a cyber attack on these con men.

    I’m putting this out here to share my plight and encourage others to act quickly and contact Morphohack if you happen to be in a similar situation. Do not believe that by paying more, you’ll be granted access to your wallet by these investment scammers. Instead, contact the Morphohack Cyber team to help you recover your crypto assets immediately.

    Their contact email is as follows: MORPHOHACK@CYBERSERVICES . COM

    Warm regards,
    Ross Colby
    Kent, Connecticut

  • vivianruss

    My husband left me for another woman a few months ago and ever since then my life has been filled with pain and agony because my husband was my first love whom I have spent my entire life with. A friend and also a colleague from work told me he saw some testimonies of a spiritualist called Doctor Muna, he can bring back lover within some few days. Ridiculously, I laughed it out and said I am not interested but for the sake of friendship, she consulted this God sent man on my behalf and to my greatest surprise after 12 hours my husband called me for the very first time for over 7 months saying “I miss you babe and I’m so sorry for everything I made you went through” I couldn’t say a word but cried over the phone and hanged up. We are back together and living Happily together again. To be honest, I still can’t believe it, because it’s highly unbelievable. Thank you DOCTOR MUNA for bringing back my love and also to my SELFLESS FRIEND. Laura, who interceded on my behalf. For anyone who might need help of this wonderful spiritualist here is the email address: marvelspelltemple@gmail.com, Also add him on WhatsApp: +2347035449257

  • Gerald Humels

    There are not many reviews about free crypto recovery fixed, but the ones that exist are mostly positive. Initially, I had no idea how that was possible until I became a victim. Some criminal got into my MetaMask and completely drained everything. I reached out to this team of Crypto Recovery gurus at: prompttechrecovery@gmail.com, in total panic. They guided me through the next steps, helped track down the address, and coordinated with legal experts. It was a long process, but I did get my funds back. However, there are also negative reviews, and I highly recommend paying attention to them. fraudsters create a fake website to con people out of money. Nothing new. These types of scams are everywhere. If you have already lost money to scammers, do not fall for another scam. Just reach out to: prompttechrecovery@gmail.com, also on Telegram: @prompttechrecovery, Or chat them up on WhatsApp +1 (484) 540 – 0785. The only tech professional I can recommend .

  • isaiahgonez966

    LOST USDT RECOVERY TESTIMONY

    If there is anyone that I trust and believe in is THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT. His like an Angel sent from heavens to rescue us from the captivity of these online scammers. After falling victim to a cryptocurrency scam group, I lost $955,000 worth of USDT. I thought all hope was lost from the experience of losing my hard-earned money to scammers. My Heart is filled with Joy and Happiness after THE HACK ANGELS RECOVERY EXPERT helped me recover my lost funds. You can also contact them if you require their assistance through their

    WhatsApp (+1(520)200-2320

    Email at support@thehackangels.com

    Website at http://www.thehackangels.com

    I am living the best life that I wanted for myself

  • frankiso12q

    IS IT POSSIBLE TO RECOVER LOST CRYPTO? YES ONLY HACKANGELS

    Hey my name is frank I’m a crypto trader! I just wanted to share my incredible experience with The Hack Angels. They are truly exceptional when it comes to crypto recovery. They managed to recover my lost $1.7 million worth of bitcoin from a scam, which I honestly thought was impossible. If you ever find yourself in a similar situation, I highly recommend reaching out to them.

    You can contact them through their hotline at +1(520)200-2320 (available on Phone/WhatsApp), or shoot them an email at support@thehackangels.com. They also have a great website at http://www.thehackangels.com if you prefer that route.

    If you’re in London, you can even visit them in person at their office located at 45-46 Red Lion Street, London WC1R 4PF, UK. They’re super helpful and really know their stuff! Don’t hesitate to reach out if you need help!

  • Anonymous

    want to express my sincere appreciation for all the work you and your team has done for me in retrieving my USDT assets from a cheating investment platform that I acquainted myself with through their broker agent on LinkedIn. I was not sure what I was getting myself into when I spoke with you a month ago…I did not think you could get my USDT assets extracted from the scammers as soon as you did. I was very skeptical at first because it was my first time hearing of someone not to mention a firm capable of tracing and retrieving digital assets lost to fraudulent transactions. After being turned down for a withdrawal request, I approached their support desk and the agent for assistance but to my dismay they were asking me for some sort of settlement each time before I Could withdraw my funds. A friend from work said to look up ” PROMPTTECH RECOVERY AGENT ” in the Internet and so I did. After going through about a dozen different infos on firm’s and recovery agents, I was getting a bit discouraged then I finally saw your ’ PROMPTTECH RECOVERY info and liked the reviews I read. No red-flags went off so I decided to make contact. It was an easy, laid-back conversation explaining everything that can be done to recoup my digital assets and improve my financial situation. It sounded good to me so I took you up on your offer. In just three days of hard work on THIS GREAT team’s part, my USDT assets was successfully recovered from the scam platform. I realize not everyone has the same recovery problems but you folks were fast and really worked for me and am assured your services will help many others as well, you can contact the firm using their contact information below:

    EMAIL: prompttechrecovery@gmail.com

    TELEGRAM: @PROMPTTECHRECOVERY

    WHATSAPP: +1 (484) 540-0785

  • dejanaivica37

    TANGIBLE INFORMATION ABOUT CHRISTMAS LOAN FOR PLANNING…
    This is not a normal post that you see every day on the internet where people make false statements and false information about huge financial assistance.. I am aware that many of you have been scammed and that fake agents have taken advantage of those seeking loans. I will not call this a normal statement, I will call this situation where I live a witness to how you can get your loan when you meet the company’s requirements. It really does not matter to have a good credit rating or government approval, all you need is a valid ID card and a valid IBAN number to be able to apply for a loan with an interest rate of 3%. The minimum amount is 1000 euros and the maximum amount that can be borrowed is 100,000,000 euros. I give you a 100% guarantee that you can get your loan through this reliable and honest company, we operate 24 hours online and provide loans to all citizens of Europe and outside Europe. They sent me a document that was checked and tested as valid before I got the loan, so I invite anyone who needs a loan to visit them or contact them via
    Email: michaelgardloanoffice@gmail.com
    WhatsApp for Europe: +385915608706
    WhatsApp for USA: +1 (717) 826-3251
    After you contact them, let them know that Ms. Dejana Ivica from Zagreb gave you the information. Seeing is believing and you will thank me later when you get a loan from them. I made a promise that after I get a loan from them, I will post the good news to everyone online. If you have friends or relatives, including colleagues, you can tell them about this offer and that it is happening this CHRISTMAS.

  • Norah Lina

    IF YOU WANT TO RECOVER YOUR STOLEN BTC CONTACT GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER FOR ALL KINDS OF HACKING JOBS

    The internet today is full of scammers. But here is some good news to everyone who has been a victim of internet scammers. You can get your money back from the scammers. If you have been a victim to internet scammers, then you should contact GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER. I have been a victim of online scams. I lost $723,000 worth of BTC. I saw where so many people recommended GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER. Hackers who have dedicated time to helping individuals to get back their money from internet scammers. Recovering lost Bitcoin can require unique hacking skills and expertise that are possessed by only a handful of professional hackers, it’s best to seek out a trusted hacker like GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER who can help you recover your funds. Am here to give glory to GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER. You guys did a great job for me. And all of this was done at an affordable price. Thanks a lot. To get in touch with the recovery hacker, you can contact them via email

    Email: geovcoordinateshacker@gmail.com

    Website; https://geovcoordinateshac.wixsite.com/geo-coordinates-hack

    Telegram; @Geocoordinateshacker

Let me know your thoughts!!

Verified by MonsterInsights